The White House at dusk

The Third Year of the Presidential Cycle: S&P 500 Returns Since 1928

Data through full calendar years 1928-2025. Past market behavior doesn't guarantee future results.

The third year of a US presidential term has been the strongest of the four for the S&P 500. Over the full calendar years 1928 to 2025, the index averaged a 14.0% price gain in year 3 (median 18.1%) and finished higher in 19 of 24 year-3s (79%), against an 8.1% average across all 98 years. The catch is the sample: 24 years is small, and the two most recent misses, 2011 and 2015, came after the original version of this page was written in 2010.

Every number below was calculated from daily S&P 500 closes from Yahoo Finance. You can see how it fits with other calendar patterns on the Market Stats hub.

How the term years are counted

Year 1 is the inauguration year, so the counting starts at 1929 (Hoover) and runs every four years to 2025. That makes year 2 the midterm year, year 3 the pre-election year (1931, 1935 … 2023) and year 4 the election year (1928, 1932 … 2024). A calendar-year return runs from the last close of one year to the last close of the next. Inauguration moved from March 4 to January 20 in 1937, per the National Archives, which doesn’t change which calendar year counts as year 1.

The cycle follows the election calendar, not the person. When a president died or resigned mid-term (1945, 1963, 1974), the count kept going.

Year 3 vs the other three years

Year 3 leads on every measure in the table: average, median and share of up years. Year 2, the midterm year, trails on all three.

Term year n Average Median % positive Worst Best
Year 1 (post-election) 25 7.0% 9.1% 60% -38.6% (1937) 44.1% (1933)
Year 2 (midterm) 24 3.3% 0.6% 54% -29.7% (1974) 45.0% (1954)
Year 3 (pre-election) 24 14.0% 18.1% 79% -47.1% (1931) 41.4% (1935)
Year 4 (election) 25 8.1% 11.8% 76% -38.5% (2008) 37.9% (1928)
All years 98 8.1% 11.6% 67% -47.1% 45.0%

Year 3 also holds the single worst year in the whole table, 1931’s 47.1% drop in the depths of the Depression. Its spread of outcomes (a standard deviation of 17.9 points) is about the same as every other year’s (19.0), so the higher average didn’t come with smaller swings.

Most published cycle studies start after World War II. Starting in 1950 makes year 3 look even better:

Term year n Average Median % positive
Year 1 (post-election) 19 8.4% 9.1% 63%
Year 2 (midterm) 19 4.6% 1.1% 58%
Year 3 (pre-election) 19 17.2% 18.9% 89%
Year 4 (election) 19 8.1% 11.8% 84%

Picking 1950 drops the 1931 and 1939 losses, which is part of why the number improves. Choosing the start date is one of the easiest ways to make a small-sample pattern look stronger than it is.

Every year 3, 1931-2023

Here is each pre-election year on its own. The low and high columns show the lowest and highest close of the year measured against the prior year-end close, so you can see how much ground the index gave up along the way. SPY’s total return (dividends included) is shown where SPY existed for the whole year.

Year S&P 500 price return Lowest close vs prior year-end Highest close vs prior year-end SPY total return
1931 -47.07% -49.67% 18.45%
1935 41.37% -15.16% 41.68%
1939 -5.18% -20.70% 0.68%
1943 19.45% 1.23% 29.38%
1947 0.00% -10.00% 5.49%
1951 16.35% 1.27% 16.74%
1955 26.40% -3.89% 28.99%
1959 8.48% -2.95% 9.96%
1963 18.89% -0.65% 18.89%
1967 20.09% 0.06% 21.49%
1971 10.79% -2.16% 13.70%
1975 31.55% 2.16% 39.45%
1979 12.31% 0.02% 15.77%
1983 17.27% -1.64% 22.76%
1987 2.03% -7.54% 39.06%
1991 26.31% -5.67% 26.31%
1995 34.11% -0.03% 35.36% 38.05%
1999 19.53% -1.39% 19.53% 20.39%
2003 26.38% -8.99% 26.38% 28.18%
2007 3.53% -3.12% 10.35% 5.15%
2011 -0.00% -12.60% 8.43% 1.89%
2015 -0.73% -9.29% 3.49% 1.23%
2019 28.88% -2.35% 29.25% 31.22%
2023 24.23% -0.82% 24.58% 26.18%

A few things stand out. 1947 ended exactly flat (15.30 to 15.30). 2011 closed at 1,257.60 against 1,257.64 a year earlier, a loss of 0.003%. Those two, plus 2015, are the “flat” year-3s that kept the price record from being cleaner. Only four year-3s (1931, 1935, 1939 and 2011) saw a close more than 10% below the prior year-end, and 1987’s 39% peak gain shrank to 2% after the October crash.

How much should you trust 24 years?

Less than the headline suggests. The pattern is real in the data, but it rests on very few independent observations, and each year moves the ”% positive” figure by about 4 points.

Three checks from the script:

  • Shuffle test. Drawing 24 years at random from the 98, 100,000 times, 3.9% of the draws averaged 14.0% or more. That would look notable on its own, but four term years were compared and the best one was chosen after looking, which makes a figure like this easier to hit by luck.
  • Drop the best year. Taking out 1935’s 41.4% leaves a year-3 average of 12.8%, still above the 8.1% all-year mean. No single year makes the result.
  • Drop the Depression. Year-3s from 1943 to 2023 (n = 21) averaged 16.5%, median 18.9%, up in 86% of years.

The usual story for why year 3 is strong (administrations front-load unpopular moves and push for growth before the election) is plausible but not something these numbers can prove. Since the 2010 post, the record has also looked less one-sided: two of the four pre-election years since then (2011 and 2015) were flat to slightly down on a price basis, while 2019 and 2023 were strong.

2027 is the next year 3

By this count 2025 was year 1, 2026 is year 2, and 2027 is the next pre-election year. This page doesn’t forecast it. The history tells you how often past year-3s rose and by how much, not what the next one will do, and 24 data points spread across very different markets (the Depression, the post-war boom, the 1970s inflation, the 2010s) leave a wide range.

If you look at the cycle alongside other calendar effects, the same small-sample caution applies to December’s seasonal record and to what followed 52-week highs in December. All three are descriptions of the past, not trade signals.

Frequently asked questions

Is 2027 the third year of the presidential cycle?

Yes. The term that began with the January 2025 inauguration makes 2025 year 1, 2026 year 2 (the midterm year), 2027 year 3 and 2028 year 4, the election year. The history on this page describes past year-3s; it says nothing reliable about how 2027 will turn out.

Has the S&P 500 ever fallen in the third year of a presidential term?

Yes, four times on a price basis from 1928 to 2025: 1931 (down 47.1%), 1939 (down 5.2%), 2011 (down 0.003%, a few hundredths of a point) and 2015 (down 0.7%). 1947 finished exactly flat. With dividends included, 2011 and 2015 were small gains.

Why is the pre-election year often strong?

The usual explanation is that administrations push for a stronger economy ahead of the election and take unpopular steps early in a term. That is a theory. The return data shows the pattern but cannot prove the cause, and with 24 observations a few big years carry a lot of the average.

Is the presidential cycle statistically significant?

Weakly. In a shuffle test, 3.9% of random groups of 24 years from 1928-2025 averaged as much as year 3 did. That looks notable, but four term years were compared and the strongest was picked after the fact, which makes a result like this easier to find by chance.

Do these returns include dividends?

No. The main tables use the S&P 500 price index, which leaves out dividends. For year-3s since 1995 the page also shows SPY's total return, which includes them and came out higher than the price return in every one of those years.

Sources

  1. S&P 500 index daily closes (^GSPC), Yahoo Finance (checked November 8, 2026)
  2. SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) adjusted closes, Yahoo Finance (checked November 8, 2026)
  3. National Archives, FDR Library blog: the 20th Amendment and the move of Inauguration Day to January 20 (1937) (checked November 8, 2026)

Jordan Whitfield

Editor, Trading the Odds

Jordan Whitfield edits Trading the Odds, which covers stock market statistics (seasonality, volatility and how markets behave around recurring events) and how prediction markets work and where they are legal. Market statistics on the site are calculated from public index data and say when the data runs through; every legal claim carries the date it was checked and a link to its source. How we check facts.