A monitor showing an orange line running above a blue line

Volatility Risk Premium (Part I): How Often the VIX Beats Realized Volatility

Data through VIX closes January 2, 1990 to October 8, 2026 (the last day with a full 21-session window after it); S&P 500 closes through November 6, 2026. Past market behavior doesn't guarantee future results.

The volatility risk premium is the gap between the volatility option traders price in and the volatility that actually shows up. For the S&P 500 it has been there most of the time: from January 2, 1990 to October 8, 2026 (9,256 trading days), the VIX closed above the index’s realized volatility over the next 21 sessions on 86.78% of days, by 4.43 points on average (an average VIX of 19.43 against 15.00 realized).

When this series first ran in October 2014, it went straight to switching rules for volatility ETNs. This rebuild starts one step earlier, with the measurement those rules sit on. Part II covers measuring it in real time, Part III the risks, and the strategy test a hypothetical rule built on it.

What the volatility risk premium measures

The premium compares two numbers in the same unit, annualized volatility points. One is forward-looking and quoted every day; the other is only known a month later.

  • Implied volatility: the VIX. Cboe describes the VIX as the market’s expectation of 30-day S&P 500 volatility, calculated from SPX option prices. The current method launched on September 22, 2003, and Cboe publishes values back to January 1990 (Cboe methodology).
  • Realized volatility. The standard deviation of the S&P 500’s daily log returns over the next 21 trading days (about one calendar month), annualized with the square root of 252.

The gap is VIX minus realized. Two technical points make it run slightly wide. The VIX is the square root of expected variance, which is a bit higher than expected volatility whenever volatility itself moves. And the VIX covers 30 calendar days, while 21 sessions is the closest trading-day match.

Sample n Avg VIX Avg next-21-day realized vol Avg gap (pts) Median gap (pts) % VIX above realized
Every trading day 9256 19.43 15.00 4.43 4.95 86.78
First trading day of each month (non-overlapping) 442 19.48 14.96 4.52 5.10 85.52

Daily observations overlap (each 21-day window shares 20 days with the next), so 9,256 overstates how many independent tests this is. The one-per-month sample, 442 months that don’t overlap, tells the same story.

The premium year by year

The average gap was positive in 36 of the 37 calendar years (2026 counts through October 8). 2008 is the only negative year, and the share of days with VIX above realized ranged from 61.26% (2008) to 100% (2003, 2017 and 2023).

Year n days Avg VIX Avg next-21-day RV Avg gap Median gap % days VIX above
1990 253 23.06 15.03 8.03 8.74 96.44
1991 252 18.37 13.13 5.24 5.24 90.08
1992 254 15.45 9.26 6.19 6.07 99.61
1993 253 12.69 8.24 4.45 4.50 95.26
1994 252 13.93 9.37 4.55 4.79 94.84
1995 252 12.39 7.82 4.57 4.97 96.43
1996 254 16.44 11.10 5.34 6.26 88.98
1997 251 22.36 17.28 5.09 5.40 89.24
1998 252 25.60 18.15 7.45 8.35 86.11
1999 251 24.37 17.86 6.51 6.61 97.61
2000 252 23.32 21.31 2.00 3.10 68.65
2001 248 25.75 19.18 6.57 7.33 80.24
2002 252 27.29 24.52 2.78 3.44 71.83
2003 252 21.98 15.29 6.69 6.20 100.00
2004 252 15.48 10.74 4.74 4.41 98.02
2005 252 12.81 9.92 2.89 3.07 90.08
2006 251 12.81 9.28 3.53 3.86 93.23
2007 251 17.54 15.51 2.03 2.58 67.73
2008 253 32.69 34.77 -2.07 1.16 61.26
2009 252 31.48 23.56 7.92 8.23 96.43
2010 252 22.55 16.08 6.46 7.74 86.51
2011 252 24.20 20.55 3.65 5.06 84.92
2012 250 17.80 12.29 5.51 5.24 99.20
2013 252 14.23 10.52 3.71 4.04 86.11
2014 252 14.18 10.82 3.35 3.72 78.17
2015 252 16.67 14.59 2.08 2.95 79.37
2016 252 15.83 11.05 4.77 5.49 87.30
2017 251 11.09 6.49 4.60 4.79 100.00
2018 251 16.64 15.68 0.96 3.61 61.35
2019 252 15.39 10.80 4.58 5.35 85.32
2020 253 29.25 26.50 2.75 8.96 76.68
2021 252 19.66 12.51 7.15 7.10 95.63
2022 251 25.62 23.28 2.35 2.48 67.33
2023 250 16.87 12.20 4.67 4.38 100.00
2024 252 15.61 12.15 3.45 3.91 82.14
2025 250 18.96 15.10 3.87 6.27 85.20
2026 (to Oct 8, 2026) 193 18.17 12.53 5.64 5.53 95.34

Look at 2020: the median gap was 8.96 points, one of the widest in the table, yet the average was only 2.75. A few weeks in February and March pulled the average down. That pattern, a steady premium most days and a few days that wipe out a lot of it, is what Part III is about.

Does a higher VIX mean a bigger premium?

In points, yes. The average gap rises from 3.03 when the VIX is under 15 to 7.02 when it is between 30 and 40. But the premium also gets less reliable at the very top: with the VIX at 40 or higher, it beat realized volatility on 79.81% of days, the lowest of any band.

VIX on the day n days Avg VIX Avg next-21-day RV Avg gap Median gap % VIX above
Under 15 2962 12.81 9.78 3.03 3.76 86.93
15 to 20 2870 17.30 12.87 4.43 5.30 88.36
20 to 25 1824 22.28 17.33 4.95 6.08 84.81
25 to 30 864 27.17 21.19 5.98 7.14 85.19
30 to 40 528 33.44 26.42 7.02 8.93 89.39
40 and up 208 50.20 43.68 6.52 8.98 79.81

The 40-and-up band has only 208 days, 125 of them in 2008 and 2009 and 35 in 2020, so it is really three episodes. Treat it as a small sample.

The big exceptions

The premium fails worst when a shock arrives while the VIX is still calm. Below are the ten largest misses, keeping only the worst day of each episode (at least 42 sessions apart). The VIX number is that day’s close; the realized number is what the next 21 sessions delivered.

Day (VIX close) VIX Realized vol, next 21 days Gap (pts)
Feb 19, 2020 14.38 82.25 -67.87
Sep 12, 2008 25.66 73.42 -47.76
Mar 25, 2025 17.15 48.09 -30.94
Jul 25, 2011 19.35 46.07 -26.72
Aug 10, 2015 12.23 30.21 -17.98
Jun 28, 2002 25.40 41.98 -16.58
Oct 22, 1997 19.86 35.86 -16.00
Dec 3, 2018 16.44 30.94 -14.50
Jan 26, 2018 11.08 25.51 -14.43
Apr 22, 2010 16.47 29.59 -13.12

And the stress years, counted by how many days the VIX ended up below what followed:

Year n days Days VIX below realized % of days Avg gap Worst day (gap)
1998 252 35 13.89 7.45 Aug 25, 1998 (-12.78)
2002 252 71 28.17 2.78 Jun 28, 2002 (-16.58)
2008 253 98 38.74 -2.07 Sep 12, 2008 (-47.76)
2011 252 38 15.08 3.65 Jul 25, 2011 (-26.72)
2018 251 97 38.65 0.96 Dec 3, 2018 (-14.50)
2020 253 59 23.32 2.75 Feb 19, 2020 (-67.87)
2022 251 82 32.67 2.35 Apr 20, 2022 (-13.08)
2025 250 37 14.80 3.87 Mar 25, 2025 (-30.94)

1998 is the surprise. The S&P 500 fell 19.34% from its high to its low within that year, yet the VIX averaged 25.60, well above its 19.43 long-run average, so it was already pricing a lot of movement. The average gap (7.45) is the third largest in the yearly table. The sign flips most often in long grinding years (2008, 2018, 2022, each above 32% of days), while the deepest single misses come from sudden shocks out of quiet markets (2020, 2015, early 2018).

Across all 9,256 days, the gap was positive 86.78% of the time and averaged 6.08 points when it was. On the other 13.22% of days it averaged -6.42, and the extremes are lopsided: +31.55 points at best, -67.87 at worst.

What this does and doesn’t show

It shows that SPX options have, on most days since 1990, priced more volatility than the index then delivered. It doesn’t show a return anyone earned. The VIX itself can’t be bought or sold, and the products that try to collect this gap (short options, short VIX futures, the old inverse-VIX notes) each add costs and risks of their own. Part II looks at how much of the premium you can see in advance, and what the VIX futures products were.

These are historical statistics, not a forecast or a recommendation. More studies on the Market Stats page, including the Williams VIX Fix.

Every number above was calculated from Cboe’s VIX history and S&P 500 closes, listed under Sources.

Frequently asked questions

What is the volatility risk premium?

It is the gap between the volatility option prices imply and the volatility that actually follows. For the S&P 500, the usual yardstick is the VIX minus the realized volatility of the next month. From 1990 to October 2026 that gap averaged 4.43 points.

Is the VIX usually higher than realized volatility?

Yes. On 86.78% of trading days since January 1990, the VIX closed above the S&P 500's realized volatility over the following 21 sessions. Using one day per month instead of every day gives 85.52%.

Why is implied volatility usually higher than realized volatility?

The common explanation is that option sellers take on the risk of sudden crashes and want to be paid for it, while buyers of puts are willing to pay up for protection. There is also a measurement effect: the VIX is built from expected variance, which sits slightly above expected volatility when volatility itself moves around.

When does the volatility risk premium turn negative?

When a shock arrives while the VIX is still low. The largest miss in the data came on February 19, 2020, when the VIX closed at 14.38 and the S&P 500's realized volatility over the next 21 sessions was 82.25. 2008 is the only calendar year since 1990 with a negative average gap.

Sources

  1. Cboe: VIX Index daily history (VIX_History.csv) (checked November 8, 2026)
  2. S&P 500 index daily closes (^GSPC), Yahoo Finance (checked November 8, 2026)
  3. Cboe: Volatility Index Methodology, Cboe Volatility Index (VIX) (checked November 8, 2026)
  4. Cboe: VIX Index product page (checked November 8, 2026)

Jordan Whitfield

Editor, Trading the Odds

Jordan Whitfield edits Trading the Odds, which covers stock market statistics (seasonality, volatility and how markets behave around recurring events) and how prediction markets work and where they are legal. Market statistics on the site are calculated from public index data and say when the data runs through; every legal claim carries the date it was checked and a link to its source. How we check facts.